“Field of Magic: Baseball’s Superstitions,
Curses and Taboos”

The author:
John Cairney
The publishing info:
McFarland
215 pages; $29.95
Released January 20, 2023
The links:
The publishers website
The authors website
At Bookshop.org
At Powells.com
At Vromans.com
At TheLastBookStoreLA
At Skylight Books
At Diesel Books
At PagesABookstore.com
At BarnesAndNoble.com
At Amazon.com
The review in 90 feet or less
In October, 1981, a column in the Boston Herald American by a Chicago writer named Ron Berler sold us a story that claimed “it is utterly impossible for a team with three or more ex-Cubs to win the World Series.” Call is ECF for short. There is no little blue pill solution for it.
Berler’s theory noted a pattern he observed since 1945, which had been the last time the Cubs were in the World Series. He found 13 teams with at least three ex-Cubs on their roster that made it to the Fall Classic over that 36-year period. And 12 of them lost. He was probably also painfully aware that Cubs’ history was all about having to shoulder such things as cursed billy goats and inopportune black cats.
By Berler’s theory, at the time it came out, the Dodgers’ eventual winning the World Series in ‘81 was only logical – the Yankees actually had five ex-Cubs on their roster at the time. The Dodgers had only two – Burt Hooton and Rick Monday. Soon after, they would dispatch Davey Lopes, Ron Cey and Jay Johnstone to the Cubs – the essence of being sent out to pasture.

But it also explained how the Dodgers’ ’77 and ’78 World Series losses to the Yankees.

In ’77, their ex-Cubs contingent was just Hooton (who spent ’71 to ’75 with Chicago) until the Dodgers added Monday and relief pitcher Mike Garman (’76) in a deal for Bill Bucker and Ivan de Jesus.

In ’78, Berler noted that the Dodgers rid themselves of Garman but replaced him with outfielder Billy North, who came via Oakland in that odd Glenn Burke deal but had Cubs’ DNA in him from ’71 and ’72.
Actually, Garman was still with the Dodgers when North arrived and they overlapped three days before Garman was traded to Montreal in late May for a two young arms.
Berler can also explain how the ’66 Dodgers were humiliated by Baltimore a year after defeating Minnesota for the title. In ’65, they had just Jim Brewer and Lou Johnson as their ex-Cubs. In ’66, they added outfielder Wes Covington and made it three. Not a good move.
At last, the 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks, which included former Cubs star Mark Grace, won the World Series against the Yankees. It caused Grace, who had spent the previous 13 seasons in Chicago, to declare: “We beat the ex-Cub Factor.” Also on those D’backs were ex-Cubs outfielder Luis Gonzalez (who had the Game 7 game-winning hit off Mariano Riviera) and relief pitcher Miguel Batista.
When the Cubs won the 2016 World Series, they used 45 players during that season. Just seven years later, all of them are gone except pitcher Kyle Hendricks (who led the ’16 Cubs, and the NL, with a 2.13 ERA). One of those ex-Cubs is outfielder Jason Heyward, added to the 2023 Dodgers to go with ex-Cubs Shelby Miller (who pitched two innings for the Cubs in ’21) and Trace Thompson (35 at bats for the Cubs in ’21).
It behooves these Dodgers to release one of those three immediately. We kinda know which one. Leave no trace of why this decision is necessary.
Continue reading “Day 16 of 2023 baseball books: When you believe in things you don’t understand then you suffer … superstition ain’t the way”














