Blog

“Dangerous Danny Gardella:
Baseball’s Neglected Trailblazer
for Today’s Millionaire Athletes”

The author: Robert Elias
The details: Rowman & Littlefield, 325 pages, $39, released April 15, 2025; best found at the publisher’s website or BookShop.org

A review in 90 feet or less

Get to know Daniel Lewis Gardella. No real danger in that.

Unless you’re concerned about getting lumped in with Communists and other people up to no good for baseball’s financial success.

Robert Elias isn’t deterred.

The New York native whose journey as a university teacher went through Montreal (McGill), Boston and France (Tufts), College Park and Europe (Maryland), Geneva (Graduate Institute of International Studies) and the Bay Area (UC Berkeley and now at University of San Francisco), Elias dug in as abaseball/politics/legal studies historical researcher authoring works such as “Baseball and the American Dream: Race, Class, Gender, and the National Pastime” in 2001 and “The Empire Strikes Out: How Baseball Sold U.S. Foreign Policy and Promoted the American Way Abroad” in 2010.

Then came the two he collaborated with Pete Dreier that focused on the game’s anarchistic best in “Baseball Rebels: The Players, People, and Social Movements That Shook Up the Game and Changed America” (a finalist for the 2023 Seymour Medal) and “Major League Rebels: Baseball Battles over Workers’ Rights and American Empire,” both in 2022 and curiously by two different publishers as we noted back then.

All trails seem to lead back to this Gardella character.

Not by accident.

“In those books one person kept popping up: Danny Gardella,” Elias writes in the preface of this bio. “Apparently an obscure figure, he nevertheless appeared over and over.”

Time to flesh it out.

Continue reading “Day 18 of 2025 baseball book reviews: The Gardella Years of Living Dangerously” →

“Mets Stories I Only Tell My Friends”

The author: Art Shamsky with Matthew Silverman
The details: Triumph Books, $30, 256 pages, released March 11, 2025; best available at the publishers website and Bookshop.org.

“Get Your Tokens Ready:
The Late 1990s Road to the Subway Series”

The author: Chris Donnelly
The details: University of Nebraska Press, $34.95, 344 pages, released May 1, 2025; best available at the publishers website and Bookshop.org.

“Out of the Mouth of Babe:
Babe Ruth on Life: Pitching, Hitting,
Striking Out, and Coming Back Swinging”

The author: Kelly Bennett 
The details: Familius Publishing, 200 pages, $16.99, released April 15, 2025; best available at the publishers’ website and Bookshop.org.

“Yankees, Typewriters, Scandals
and Cooperstown: A Baseball Memoir”

The author: Bill Madden
The details: Triumph Books, 256 pages, $30, released April 1, 2025; best available at the publishers website and Bookshop.org.

---

A review in 90 feet or less

The top five loudest news stories involving New York’s professional baseball teams in 2025, starting in spring training, have been, more or less, in this order:

1. Believe it or not, Yankees players can wear hair on their face (which had many pulling out their global hair). And then they got rid of Alex Verdugo, who immediately shed a large beard as an outfielder with the Atlanta Braves.

2. The Yankees won’t stoop to playing Frank Sinatra’s “New York, New York” if they lose a home game.

3. The Yankees leased George Steinbrenner Stadium in St. Petersburg to the Tampa Bay Rays this season — and no, the Yankees won’t play “New York, New York” after they defeat them from the oddness of sitting in the visiting dugout.

4. Torpedo bats are a thing. And legal. Alex Verdugo may want to look into this.

5. New York Mets owner Steve Cohen has, according to the Sports Business Journal, “an ambitious long-term vision for the area surrounding City Field” that will cost about $8 billion to turn 50 acres of asphalt parking lots into a Hard Rock Hotel and Casino, a food hall and a 5,000-seat indoor concern venue.

And it seems to be legal for someone who the story points out is a “$21 billion hedge fund titan.”

Continue reading “Day 17 of 2025 baseball book reviews: The token torpedos of NYC book bombing” →

“3,000: Baseballs Elite Clubs
for Hits and Strikeouts”

The author: Douglas J. Jordan
The details: McFarland, $35, 232 pages, released Nov. 20, 2024; best available at the publishers website and Bookshop.org.

A review in 90 feet or less

The latest Clayton Kershaw Challenge is upon us.

It compares far less to the Hollywood portrait of Stan Ross. It’s much more up on easel with Bob Ross. If you think about thing that way.

But, why would you?

In the Bernie Mac movie from some 20 years ago, “Mr. 3,000,” Stan Ross is the prima donna designated hitter for the Milwaukee Brewers who retired in 1995 just as his team was amidst the playoff race because he reached the fabled career hit milestone, which he assumed would guarantee him Baseball Hall of Fame immortality, and that was all it seemed he was playing for.

Then came the nasty “clerical error” — three hits were taken away from him because of a rain-canceled game where the stats didn’t count. All his post-retirement “Mr. 3,000” branded endorsement deals backed out, and he couldn’t get voters to get him into Cooperstown. So at age 46, he makes a comeback. He goes hitless in his first 27 at-bats. Then, in the last at-bat of the last game of the season, he’s one hit short, but the team needs him to lay down a sacrifice bunt that could help them clinch a win that would get them a surprise third-place spot in their division.

Sacrifice himself for the good of the team? You can’t make up these scripts. Except, here, they did.

And then, some baseball scholars tried to see how he really measured up — why would he not make it in with “merely” 2,999 hits? Steroids?

(See a Harvard sports analysis on this that may make you think twice about its entitlement to public funding).

When Kershaw’s 2024 season started late and ended early — it was a -0.3 WAR performance of seven starts while the team was fully geared up for their World Series run — he found himself 32 strikeouts short of 3,000 for his career, having racked up just 24 in 30 innings over seven starts.

He was 36 years old, held out on the 60-day IL at the beginning as he recovered from a surgically repaired left shoulder, started with a four-inning game on July 25, and ended it after the first inning of a game on August 30 in Arizona because the big toe on his left foot was acting up.

The offseason seemed 50/50 on whether he’d just retire. His Hall of Fame status was already pretty well locked in. On Baseball-Reference.com, the average Hall of Famer’s “black ink” is 40 (Kershaw has 65), the “gray ink” is 185 (he has 188) and the Bill James’ Hall of Fame monitor of 100 shows Kershaw blown past that at 211. By “Hall of Fame Standards,” the average is 50, and he had 62, with a 79.2 career war, 21^st all time by a starting pitcher. His season-by-season stats compared, from age 26 to 36, to either Tom Seaver or Pedro Martinez, as well as Roy Halladay, Chief Bender, Whitey Ford and Randy Johnson. All HOFs.

(Also, we didn’t realize that on that website, it notes Kershaw’s nicknames have been “The Claw, “Kid K,” “The Minotaur,” and, of course, “Kersh.”)

Three times he led the NL in strikeouts — 248 in 2011, 232 in 2013 and a career-best 301 in 2015. Yet the last time he had a season of 200 or more Ks was 2017. A resume with three NL Cy Youngs, 10 All Star appearances and an NL MVP, already the Dodgers’ franchise leader in strikeouts …

Why bother coming back? What’s left to gain through more pain?

Continue reading “Day 15 of 2025 baseball book reviews: The mystery, the science and the theater of reaching 3,000” →

“Selling Baseball: How Superstars
George Wright and Albert Spalding
Impacted Sports in America”

The author: Jeffrey Orens
The details: Rowman & Littlefield, $35, 274 pages, released Feb. 4, 2025; best available at the publisher’s website and Bookshop.org

“Baseball’s First Superstar:
The Lost Life Story of Christy Mathewson”

The author: Alan D. Gaff
The details: University of Nebraska Press, $32.95, 240 pages, released in May, 2025; best available at the publishers website, the author’s website and Bookshop.org.

A review in 90 feet or less

Focus just on baseball’s language, with all its over-modulated adjectives and supercilious discussions. From that, how does one decide when a player moves ahead of the line from a “star” to a “superstar”?

Preferably, a superstar without a capital “S,” which seems to be treading far too close to Superman territory.

A year ago, Joe Reuter of the Bleacher Report listed his “Definitive List of MLB Players Who Deserve to Be Called a ‘Superstar’,” and established the guideline: “Being a superstar athlete is about more than just on-field performance, as major market exposure, marketability and highlight-reel skills can all help elevate a talented player to that next tier of stardom.”

They are trend setters and stop-and-watch performers, heightened by social media and all the other applicable influencers of the day.

Continue reading “Day 14 of 2025 baseball book reviews: Before a superstar smelled his (or her) armpits for validation” →