Blog

The 2025 baseball book series in review: 22 entries skidoo’d

I’ve been starving for attention.

Maybe that’s why I’m lately drawn to flip through a cookbook/self improvement project that came out last year, got a lot of nice publicity, and led to author Margaret Eby landing an NPR radio appearance (I’d already read this one awhile back on the website) to talk about all the angst that went into her writing “You Gotta Eat: Real-Life Strategies for Feeding Yourself When Cooking Feels Impossible.

Much of the explanation of force-feeding yourself to avoid starvation or anything worse is how to be more grateful and graceful when trying to sooth the soul as it encounters bouts of depression, some of it brought up just be being alive these days battling spiritual warfare from within.

One of the author’s quick-fix meals is something she said her and her husband call “The Super Bowl.” It means giving yourself the OK to just tear into a bowl of dip for dinner. And count it as a meal. Because it does.

Put together a plate of whatever you have in your fridge, like carrot sticks, pita chips, lettuce cups or tater tots, and serve with any dip: baba ganoush, chicken salad, hummus or sour cream and onion dip. Like you’d have on a Sunday in February when there’s nothing else that gives you much comfort and you’re at a friends’ house trying to stay social while an over-hyped NFL contest on the TV is far from fulfilling the psyche.

The book is something I should have applied to the last few months to pull together the latest edition of my annual series.

It’s one I could have easily labeled: “You Gotta Digest Another Baseball Book: Real-Life Strategies for Reading When Turning Another Page Feels Impossible.”

Because, in the process of feeding my brain with baseball prose, I corrupt my palate with too many odds and ends — canned bean salad mixed/shoveled with Doritos, for one — which never amount to anything healthy and only exacerbate likely own angst. There is feeding some depression, much of which is brought upon by the United States we currently live in, and the baseball books only brought a modicum of escapism.

It is with some regret that, maybe a bit too early — but better than too late — we’ve decided it’s best to cut off the book reviews after these now-established 22 posts, which cover almost three dozen titles, and focus on what we could get in between March and May of 2025. I can’t deal with any more. Besides, I got a really nice samples of some great writing so far and I’m very fulfilled at this point.

More interesting titles are expected later this summer and fall, but the point here is: What was new when the baseball season starts? What can we recommend for a day at the ballpark, beach or backyard BBQ? Or while waiting in line for the Union Station bus to take you past the parking lots to the Dodger Stadium drop off spot?

At some point, you can’t wait for more.

Thus, we have collected these posts amidst a ton of crumbs left in the La-Z-Boy recliner:

= Day 22: “Field Work” by Andrew Forbes

What did we learn: Forbes is the most valued, top-notch writer on the game today.This only confirms it. Find this and all else he has done prior for further proof. We saved the best for the last in this series.

= Day 21: “The House Divided: The Story of the First Congressional Baseball Game” by J.B. Manheim.

What did we learn: In the process of researching his sixth book of “The Deadball Files” fiction series, Manheim steamrolls into more interesting history he couldn’t help but better document as a non-fiction work for our enjoyment. It’s its own 1909 crime thriller.

= Day 20: “Baseball Like It Oughta Be: How a Shoe Salesman’s Madison Mallards And His Renegade Staff Ignited a Summer Collegiate Baseball Revolution”,” by Tom Alesia.

What did we learn: Comparing the Savannah Bananas to the Madison Mallards is like apples to oranges. You can enjoy them independently or in one big fruit salad. But for our appreciation of local history, bank on the Mallards for long-term success.

= Day 19: “Big Loosh: The Unruly Life of Umpire Ron Luciano” by Jim Leeke.

What did we learn: Unlucky Luciano just wanted to make everyone around him happy, when he was completely miserable. It caught up with him. We wish he could have got the role of Coach on “Cheers” now that we knew how much it might have meant to him.

= Day 18: “Dangerous Danny Gardella: Baseball’s Neglected Trailblazer for Today’s Millionaire Athletes” by Robert Elias.

What did we learn: Curt Flood took the baton from Danny Gardella, who had more nicknames than anyone deserved for having played in just two seasons with the New York Giants (and one token at bat with St. Louis when it was too late).

= Day 17: “Mets Stories I Only Tell My Friends” by Art Shamsky and Matthew Silverman; “Get Your Tokens Ready: The Late 1990s Road to the Subway Series” by Chris Donnelly; “Out of the Mouth of Babe: Babe Ruth on Life: Pitching, Hitting, Striking Out, and Coming Back Swinging” by Kelly Bennett; “Yankees, Typewriters, Scandals and Cooperstown: A Baseball Memoir” by Bill Madden.

What did we learn: If it’s 256 pages and can sell for $30, it’ll get done if it involves pinstripes or anything amazin’.

= Day 16: “A Time for Reflection: The Parallel Legacies of Baseball Icons Willie McCovey and Billy Williams” by Jason Cannon; “A Giant Among Giants: The Baseball Life of Willie McCovey” by Chris Haft.

What did we learn: It’s hardly a stretch to size up Willie and Billy, two Alabama gentlemen born weeks apart, Hall of Famers in so many ways.

= Day 15: “3,000: Baseballs Elite Clubs for Hits and Strikeouts” by Douglas J. Jordan.

What did we learn: Clayton Kershaw is far more comparable to Pedro Martinez than Carsten Charles (C.C.) Sabathia according to the data. And, on our pallet, far more Bob Ross than Stan Ross if he wants the title of “Mr. 3,000.”

= Day 14: “Selling Baseball: How Superstars George Wright and Albert Spalding Impacted Sports in America” by Jeffrey Orens; “Baseball’s First Superstar: The Lost Life Story of Christy Mathewson” by Alan D. Gaff.

What did we learn: A “superstar” can fit a definition, but … can he really?

= Day 13: “Baseball before We Knew It: A Search for the Roots of the Game” by David Block.

What did we learn: Twenty years after it first came out, there’s more to know that we didn’t know we knew. Comeback Book of the Year.

= Day 12: “Skipper: Why Baseball Managers Matter and Always Will” by Scott Miller; “The Last Manager: How Earl Weaver Tricked, Tormented & Reinvented Baseball” by John W. Miller.

What did we learn: We never will complain about a manager’s decision again. Because, honestly, we don’t know who made the decision. Times have changed. Also included on this post: “Hurdle-isms: Wit and Wisdom from a Lifetime in Baseball,” by Clint Hurdle; “The Dad Coach: How to Lead Kids to Succeed On and Off the Baseball Field,” by Mike Matheny with Jerry Jenkins; “The Lineup Card: An Illustrated History of the Baseball Collectible,” by Tom O’Reilly.

= Day 11: “The Baseball Stadium Guide” by Ian McArthur; “The Modern Baseball: History of MLB Through the Art of the Logoball” by Tyler Burton; “Movies With Balls: The Greatest Sports Films of All Time, Analyzed and Illustrated” by Rick Bryson and Kyle Bandujo; “Movies and the Church of Baseball: Religion in the Cinema of the National Pastime” by Jonathan Plummer.

What did we learn: Art may be in the eye of the beholder, but we really thought it was interesting when we pulled up our GPS app and found something even more arty. Also included on this post: “The Art of Baseball: The Watercolors of James Fiorentino” by James Fiorentino with John Molari; “Black Baseball’s Heyday: Capturing an Era in Art and Words,” by Anthony High and Denny Dressman.

= Day 10: “Homestand: Small Town Baseball and the Fight for the Soul of America” by Will Bardenwerper.

What did we learn: We miss the Lancaster JetHawks more than we realize. And thanks, Will, for alluding to the 100th anniversary of “The Great Gatsby.” Also included in this post: “When Minor League Baseball Almost Went Bust: 1946-1963,” edited by George Pawlush; “Extra Innings: A Memoir of Fathers, Sons, Fandom and Fate,” by Jeff Benjamin.

= Day 9: “Here Comes The Pizzer: The Found Poetry of Baseball Announcers” by Eric Poulin; “The Ancient Wisdom of Baseball: Lessons for Life from Homer’s Odyssey to the World Series” by Christian Sheppard.

What did we learn: Allow yourself the grace to take in these two books when your brain is still and the spirit isn’t agitated. Goes well with Richard Rohr’s new book, “Falling Upward: The Spirituality For the Two Halves of Life,” and you may understand this better. Or just listen to Vin Scully call a game on a YouTube.com. You’ll find poetry in motion.

= Day 8: “Jim Gilliam: The Forgotten Dodger” by Steve Dittmore; “They Changed the Game: 50 Stories and Illustrations Celebrating Creativity in Sports” by Matthew and Ariana Broerman; “Dream Merchant of the Perfect Game: The Life and Legacy of Frank ‘Doc’ Sykes” by Bernard McKenna; “Play Harder: The Triumph of Black Baseball in America” by Gerald Early.

What did we learn: DEI in this ERA may bring us a new WAR. Is this what Jack Robinson fought for? On the 2025 Jack Robinson Day, we have to wonder just what the hell is going on. We have the longest pre-amble before the reviews come of these four books because it’s necessary to properly clear our throats and our minds about what’s happening — and also didn’t happen with the Dodgers decided to visit the White House.

Also included on this post: “Opening the Door for Jackie: The Untold Story of Baseball’s Integration,” by Keith Evan Crook; “Brooklyn Dodgers Transactions, 1890–1957 — A History and Analysis,” by Lyle Spatz; “A Baseball Book of Days: Thirty-One Moments that Transformed the Game,” by Phil Coffin; “Race and Resistence in Boston: A Contested Sports History,” edited by Robert Cvornyek and Douglas Stark; Justice Batted Last: Ernie Banks, Minnie Miñoso, and the Unheralded Players Who Integrated Chicago’s Major League Teams,” by Don Zminda.

= Day 7: “All The Way: The Life of Baseball Trailblazer Maybelle Blair” by Kat D. Williams.

What did we learn: Maybelle Blair didn’t quite make our final ballot for the Baseball Reliquary’s Shrine of the Eternals. There will certainly be more opportunities for her to claim fame elsewhere.

= Day 6: “My Baseball Story: The Game’s Influence on America” by Nick Del Calzo.

What did we learn: Americans love to explain how they fell in love with baseball. Add photos if necessary.

Also included on this post: “Hey Mom, Wanna Have a Catch?: A Collection of Baseball Stories … Honoring Moms and Dads who Taught us to Love America’s National Pastime,” by Rob Sheinkopf; “9 Innings To Living Your Best Life: Achieve Success When You S.M.I.L.E.” by Jay Jackson.

= Day 5: “I Felt the Cheers: The Remarkable Silent Life of Curtis Pride” by Curtis Pride and Doug Ward.

What did we learn: The idea, as well as the fact, that Curtis Pride is still proudly identified these days as an MLB Ambassador for Inclusion since 2015 is worth mentioning right out of the batters’ box. “I am a man of faith, and Pride is one of the seven deadly sins, but I never really cared for that definition. I prefer Webster’s: ‘The quality or state of being proud.’ That was me. I was nothing if not proud—proud of my name, my family, and the circumstances I had to overcome.”

= Day 4:L.A. Story: Shohei Ohtani, The Los Angeles Dodgers, And A Season for the Ages“ by Bill Plunkett.

What did we learn: If Ohtani never pitches again, the Dodgers will be fine with it. If he does, Dodger Stadium will surpass Tokyo Disneyland more than it already has become.

= Day 3: “Don Drysdale: Up and In The Life of a Dodgers Legend” by Mark Whicker.

What did we learn: A bit of randomness as nearly 40 voices suddenly became part of the chorus that, in this manuscript, form less of a linear biographical recount but more of a round-table appreciation/tribute/eulogy.Big D’s legend could still use a full research project.

= Day 2: Baseball’s Best (and Worst) Teams: The Top (and Bottom) Clubs Since 1903” by G. Scott Thomas.

What did we learn: If you though the ’27 Yankees were the greatest team in MLB history, the data doesn’t prove it. Look at it this way: The San Diego Padres’ only two trips to the World Series came in 1984 and 1996. They lost to the No. 1 and No. 2 greatest teams ever assembled as far as Thomas’ research shows.

Also included on this post: “One More for the White Rat: The 1987 St. Louis Cardinals Chase the Pennant,” by Doug Feldmann; “1960: When the Pittsburgh Pirates Had Them All The Way,” by Wayne Stewart; “White Sox Redemption: The Road to World Series Victory in 2005,” by Dan Helpinstine; “The Whiz Kids: How the 1950 Phillies Took the Pennant, Lost the World Series and Changed Philadelphia Baseball Forever,” by Dennis Snelling; “The Boys of ’62: Inspiring Story of the San Pedro Little League Champs,” by Tim Urish.

= Day 1: “JapanBall: Travel Guide to Japanese Baseball” by Gabe Lerman; “A Baseball Gaijin: Chasing A Dream to Japan and Back” by Aaron Fischman; “Makeshift Fields: Chasing Baseball Across Ireland, Scotland, England and Wales” by Dale Jacobs.

What did we learn: Where else can the Dodgers open a season to plant more seeds? Having already been to Australia, South Korea and Japan, it seems Great Britain should be next on the list. Or maybe Alaska.


Among the books we waited, and waited, and waited for, didn’t see coming out and decided to at least mention them for future pursuits:

== “Dodgers to Damascus: David Lesch’s Journey from Baseball to the Middle East,” by Catherine Nixon Cooke (Trinity University Press, $39.95, 284 pages, due in October). The Dodgers drafted Lesch, a 6-foot-3 right-handed pitcher from Central Arizona College in the first round of the January regular-phase. At age 20, he spent one season at the team’s Pioneer League affiliate in Alberta, Canada, posting a 1-0 record in five games and was done with a shoulder injury. Only four players, none really of note, made it to the MLB level. Lesch became a distinguished professor of Middle East studies and was soon tapped by the United Nations, the U.S. State Department, and policy centers and governments internationally.

== “Touching Home: Baseball and the Liberal-Republican Tradition in America,” by Mary Craig (University of Missouri Press, 234 pages, $45, due in October).

== “Make Me Commissioner: I Know What’s Wrong with Baseball and How to Fix It,” by Jane Leavy (Grand Central Publishing/Hatchette, 384 pages, $32.50, due in September). From the no-nonsense biographer of Mickey Mantle, Sandy Koufax and Babe Ruth, Leavy does her homework by probing such figures as Dave Roberts, Joe Torre, Jim Palmer and Dusty Baker.

== 72 Stories by Geddy Lee (Harper Collins, $50, 160 pages); The Music of Baseball: A History and Catalog of Selected Works by George Boziwick (McFarland, $49.95, 120 pages);1978: Baseball and America in the Disco Era” by David Krell (University of Nebraska Press, $34.95, 224 pages, released April 1, 2025).

This was to be a mashup post to celebrate baseball and music but we couldn’t fine tune it in time. La te da. Of the three, Krell’s book has been out awhile. It is the third installment of a rather one-note idea where he picks a year and attaches pop culture references to it on a monthly basis, already doing much with 1962 (published in 2021) and 1966 (out in 2023). His next one is on 1986. These have been called “workmanlike,” which is a nicer way of saying template-filling with little connecting of dots or providing some post-experience enlightenment. Krell describes his book in a March 3, 2025 post on UNP, so there you go. He’s found a way to keep on telling stories.

The $50 coffee-table sized extravaganza by Geddy Lee Weinrib, best known as Geddy Lee, Toronto-born lead vocalist, bassist and keyboards for Rush since he joined in 1968, will have its niche audience as he relieves this odd collection of baseballs he’s pulled together over the years. Listen, they still start each game singing the National Anthem. Why again? Maybe to some, singing “Tom Sawyer” makes more sense. We maybe got the gist of this when Lee creepily walked Dan Rather through the collection for an AXS TV interview show. The Harper Collins book is a scaled down version of the one sold earlier on the Rush website to hard-core collectors.

== “Bo Belinsky: The Rise, Fall and Rebound of a Playboy Pitcher,” by David Krell (McFarland Books, $29.95, perhaps coming out in the summer). This seems to be an extension of what Krell came upon on Belinsky in his books covering 1962 and ’66 and thought it was worth doing a deeper dive. In our ongoing series “SoCal Sports History 101,” we cover Belinsky for wearing No. 36 for the Angels from ’62 to ’64 before he was traded after slugging a local sportswriter. Belinsky did his own book, “Pitching and Wooing” in 1973 at the height of Jim Bouton’s “Ball Four.” Maybe too little and too late for Bo, who died in 2001 at age 64.

== “Baseball’s Most Outrageous Promotions: From Wedlock to Headlock Day to Disco Demolition Night,” by Joseph Natalicchio (McFarland Books, $29.95, 209 pages, perhaps coming out in October). Lots of material to go through from 1946 to the 1980s.

== “White Sox Redemption: The Road to World Series Victory in 2005,” by Dan Helpinstine (McFarland Books, $29.95, perhaps coming out in July). Already briefly mentioned in the Day 2 books focused on particular teams, we’re guessing that based on the recent news from Rome and Pope Leo XIV, this book should already have been pulled for a rewrite and had the word “redemption” changed to “miracle.”

== “America’s Ballparks: A Trip Across the Country to Visit Baseball’s Playing Fields, Old and New,” by Nancy J. Hajeski (Schiffer Books, $45, perhaps due in September). That’s Dodger Stadium on the bottom half of the cover. This somehow looks like a remake of a remake, but we can’t put our finger on it. Yet.

== “Baseball in the Roaring Twenties: The Yankees, the Cardinals, and the Captivating 1926 Season” by Thomas Wolf (University of Nebraska Publishing, $36.95, 256 pages, due in September). Wolf wrote “The Called Shot: Babe Ruth, the Chicago Cubs, and the Unforgettable Major League Baseball Season of 1932” for UNP in 2020, and it was a finalist for the Seymour Medal from the Society for American Baseball Research).

== “Attorneys in the Baseball Hall of Fame,” edited by Louis H. Schiff and Robert M. Jarvis (McFarland Books, $45, due in July). Get to know three players (Hughie Jennings, Jim O’Rourke and Monte Ward), two managers (Miller Huggins and Tony La Russa), three executives (Larry MacPhail, Walter O’Malley and Branch Rickey) as told to by law professor and a retired Florida county court judge.

== Stan Musial,” edited by Bill Nowlin and Glen Sparks with Len Levin and Carl Riechers (SABR, 160 pages, $34.95, released in June). Brooklyn Dodgers gave Musial his nickname – “The Man” – in 1946. Here, 34 SABR members contribute essays and research on his career.

== “The New Baseball Bible: Notes, Nuggets, Lists, and Legends from Our National Pastime — Third Edition,” by Dan Schlossberg (Sports Publishing/Skyhorse, 488 pages, $29.99, due out in June). First published as The Baseball Catalog in 1980, we reviewed the 2020 update (at 465 pages) that came out during the COVID shutdown in June of that year and found it a great way to pass the time. The update found a way to get Shohei Ohtani on the cover to show it is truly an update from previous editions. Schlossberg is the former Associated Press sports editor from New Jersey, a regular writer for Street & Smith’s Official Baseball Yearbook, Sports Collectors Digest, The Sporting News and official World Series programs. His resume includes more than three dozen books.

Post script: I’ve got a hunch that Doug Glanville, who in 2010 came out with “The Game from Where I Stand: A Ballplayer’s Inside View,” will have to bind a collection the best-of essays he’s been posting on his Substack account, “Welcome to Glanville,” one of the most insightful things about the game and life that’s apt to be unlocked and fall into your in-box during the week. I’ve been a Glanville fan since we talked for a 2019 post about Jackie Robinson Day that led to an L.A. Times media column, and the experience he revealed about discrimination he had during a visit to LAX in 2015. Glanville once taught a class at his alma mater, Penn, called “Communications, Sports and Social Justice” that focused on how sports messages were crafted to effect change on society.

Day 22 of 2025 baseball book reviews: Working on a dream

“Field Work: On Baseball and Making a Living”

The author: Andrew Forbes
The details: Assembly Press, 222 pages, $17.95, released April 15, 2025; best available at the publisher website and the author’s website.

A review in 90 feet or less

Workshop this idea in a press box near you: The job of anyone writing about the game of baseball today is to make sure the contest below remains imperfectly perfect.

Baseball’s imperfections are what makes it most relatable to its fan base. It’s all a work of failures and resolutions, a work in progress. Yet we seem to define progress oddly in a time of mandated pitch clocks, video reviews by detached persons in New York and the potential of robotic ball-strike calls from a digital platform, all of which looks like a video game, trying to size up an imprecise boundary idea of a strike zone because we aim to get things as right as possible.

Baseball doesn’t even get the definition right of a perfect game.

For years, it’s assumed a contest in which the pitcher (or in today’s game, a bullpen strung along like Christmas lights) gets 27 straight outs without allow a batter to reach base by any sort of feat or accident. I’ve told the story before about being at a game in the ballpark, and a young couple sitting behind me was reduced to boyfriend-splaining.

The guy pointed out to his gal pal that, at the moment, the pitcher had no-hitter going.

“Too bad it’s not a perfect game,” he added.

“What’s that?” she replied.

“A perfect game,” he started, hesitated, and continued, “is when the pitcher strikes everyone out on three pitches.”

I pondered turning around to perhaps tighten up that response, but I resisted because, upon further review in my frontal lobe, he was more right than wrong. Someone in a press box likely called the first one of these things “perfect” — a “perfecto” if they were of another language enabler — and it stuck.

Even then, if someone actually achieved a perfect game as this lad described it, someone would modify the feat and raise the bar to defining it as an Immaculate Game, and then we’d get all the religious zealots involved in hijacking their bibles.

Where does all this brain-wave baseball philosophy come from?

For me, it’s from reading another Andrew Forbes book. And not possible able to match his output but only try to keep pace.

Continue reading “Day 22 of 2025 baseball book reviews: Working on a dream”

Day 21 of 2025 baseball book reviews: Who has the veto power on an overturned call in this game?

“The House Divided:
The Story of the First
Congressional Baseball Game”

The author: J.B. Manheim
The details: Sunbury Press, $19.95, 182 pages, released April 22, 2025. Best available at the publisher’s website and the author’s website.

A review in 90 feet or less

Updated 6.12.25

No, no. Nannette Diaz Barragán has earned her roster spot for the Congressional Baseball Game, next up on June 11 at Nationals Park in the District of Columbia.

Since 2017 when the freshman House rep put on a Los Angeles Dodgers’ jersey, highlighted by a red No. 44 to represent her district, then ripped a pinch-hit, RBI-single in her first appearance before 25,000, Barragán continues to use baseball as a way of proving her worthiness.

This is no DEI seat filler. Her bio is pretty explicit in the ability to challenge and respond to situations.

Born in Harbor City as the youngest of 11, Nanette Diaz went to North Torrance High. While she played softball, she also petitioned the administration to be allowed to try out for the boys’ baseball team — and she made the JV squad.

With degrees in political science and public policy from UCLA and a doctorate in law from USC, she launched into a legal career. Involved in the Clinton White House in the Office of Public Liaison for African American outreach, Barragán eventually moved to Florida in 2012 to work on Barack Obama’s presidential re-election campaign and be part of the voter’s rights protection team.

By 2013, she circled back to the Hermosa Beach City Council, fighting against offshore oil drilling. Two years later, she was running for Congress after Janice Hahn vacated the seat.

After her debut in the Congressional Game in ’17, she was noted as one of three participants in the ’18 games — which marked the 25th anniversary of when Blanche Lambert Lincoln, Illena Ros-Lehtinen and Maria Cantwell were the first women played.

“A lot has changed in 25 years,” Barragán said, “but when it comes to this sort of thing, we need to acknowledge not much progress has been made.”

For the 2019 game, Barragán and good friend Linda Sanchez (CA-38) were the only two women players. Barragán invited the D.C. Girls Baseball Team as her special guest, taking pride int he fact her 44th District — Carson, Compton, Lynwood, North Long Beach, Rancho Dominguez, San Pedro, South Gate, Walnut Park, Watts, Willowbrook and Wilmington — includes the Compton Youth Baseball Academy, which hosts annual girls baseball tournaments.

With decisive victories in re-elections in ’18, ’20, ’22 and ’24, Barragán doesn’t hide her love of the Dodger blue, introduced to her by her father. She was at the Dodgers’ White House visits after their 2020 and ’24 World Series titles. Her official website has fashioned a branding for her that looks like the Dodgers’ logo.

With Sanchez as the captain of Team Democrat for the ’25 game, Barragán finds herself as the only woman on the roster. She is there with fellow Californian House members Pete Aguiliar (CA-33), Gil Cisneros (CA-31), Adam Gray (CA-13), Mike Levin (CA-49), Dave Min (CA-47), Kevin Mullin (CA-15), Raul Ruiz (CA-25), Eric Swalwell (CA-15), Derek Tran (CA-45), plus as U.S. senator Alex Padilla.

Four women are listed on the Republican roster — Lisa McClain (MI-09), Mariannette Miller-Meeks (IA-01), Kat Cammack (FL-03) and Iowa senator Joni Ernst.

Continue reading “Day 21 of 2025 baseball book reviews: Who has the veto power on an overturned call in this game?”

Day 20 of 2025 baseball book reviews: What’s good for the Mallards is good for goosing the game

“Baseball Like It Oughta Be:
How a Shoe Salesman’s Madison Mallards
And His Renegade Staff Ignited a
Summer Collegiate Baseball Revolution”

The author: Tom Alesia
The details: August Publications, $18.95; 208 pages, released May 19, 2025; best available at the publishers website and the author’s website

A review in 90 feet or less

Updated 6.2.25

There oughta be a clear path for someone like Lauren Thiesen to write a piece for Defector.com under the headline: “The Savannah Bananas Make Baseball Boring” and not be weary of getting crapped on for it. Especially when she framed it as coming “the perspective of a baseball nut and ‘sports entertainment’ obsessive.”

Read it for yourself. Good points are made.

She followed it up with a Facebook post: “I was a tiny bit miffed by the handful of ‘this reads like an old man wrote it’ responses … You can disagree with my (nuanced!) thoughts, but idk why it would ever be inconceivable that a 30 yr old woman produced them.”

Especially from a target audience member for the traveling hardball show.

When we visited the Bananas’ second game of a two-day appearance at Angels Stadium in Anaheim this week — perhaps the only two sellouts at the place this 2025 calendar year, coming off a three-game series against the Yankees — we had Thiesen’s words in our head as a frame of reference, as well as local media coverage from the Day 1 game, but otherwise, we tried to be open-minded.

Our take on the whole idea of the Savannah Bannanas and the comparison to the Harlem Globetrotters:

It’s more more “High School Musical” meshed with Horsehide Cirque du Soleil, a wedding reception with a baseball theme wrapped around an activity that looks like a game played at the pace of a batting-practice pitcher grab-and-throw-and-grove. The between-innings experiences of corny planned contests, honoring veterans and first responders, and even a shout out to a non-profit Foster kids program doesn’t drag anything down but allows for catching one’s breath.

And it works.

A DJ-stage gathering to amp up the noise and energy before, then the “show” starts, then the after-party. Perhaps an exhausting pace for some, but it’s taking the elements of action of a “regular” baseball game and heightening it, expanding it, and amping it up. It takes advantage of incorporating local entertainment nods (Disneyland, for sure) and really knows how to read the room. It works in a baseball stadium best (because of the setup with scoreboards, wifi and capacity seating depth) but wedging it as well into a football stadium or other venue will add to its quirkiness.

It’s scripted schizophrenia, pumped up performance art, wonky scorekeeping and incredible talent on display surrounding the unplanned elements of game that has to be a communal stadium experience in person instead of judging it by a Tik Tok video clip or another high light reel. There are surprise guests. There’s a mascot, “Split,” that, at least in Anaheim, dared go up into the batters’ eye area beyond center field and do what every kid has wanted to do: Roll down the green hill.

Sensory overload, but not in a toxic way. Baseball remains the framework amidst all the improve and sketch comedy. The organizers do all they can to prevent the sale of $75 going for $1,000 or more on the open market, but that’s the world we live in — those taking advantage of a situation. Hopefully, you have karma lottery and get the best seats possible (another key to the experience) and bring in as many friends who otherwise might not enjoy a “real” baseball game to see this thing under the circus tent.

Back to how Thiesen ended her essay: “So what does someone want to see in a Savannah Bananas game? I guess they want to see the players dance. But they saw that already online. There’s no need to go to the stadium and catch it again with a worse view. Just give your minor-league boys a shot this summer. They’re probably doing something almost as weird.”

That’s where Tom Alesia starts making his case for the Madison Mallards.

The book is not just on what this college summer-league team has done, continue to do, and likely will do for years to come, but why it resonates in the community, and why it doesn’t need to try to out-gimmick anyone else by trying to be a national attraction, and how it can be content in how it has kept the game relevant in a non-MLB sphere.

It has a formula. It works.

Comparing Mallards to Bananas is more like Granny Smith apples to Cara Cara oranges. They’re each sweet and special in their own fruity way. (And that’s aside from the fact the forward to Alesia’s book is written by John Kovalic, the creator of the fantastic “Apples To Apples” card game.)

Continue reading “Day 20 of 2025 baseball book reviews: What’s good for the Mallards is good for goosing the game”

Day 19 of 2025 baseball book reviews: Unlucky Luciano’s last out

“Big Loosh: The Unruly Life
of Umpire Ron Luciano”

The author: Jim Leeke
The details: University of Nebraska Publishing, $32.95, 216 pages, to be released in July 1, 2025; best available at the publishers website and bookshop.org.

A review in 90 feet or less

The Los Angeles Times sports section of July 11, 1970 features a series of Ron Luciano photos, showing the second-year AL umpire in all “study of emotions” on the first-base line during a game at Anaheim Stadium.

In the 1980s, the baseball media world could count on three things:

= A movie that directors insisted “was not a baseball film at all but really one about (fill in the blank)” made it as a big box-office draw. The lineup included “The Natural” (1984), “Bull Durham” (1988), “Eight Men Out” (1988), “Field of Dreams” (1988) and “Major League (1989);

= Hearing John Fogerty’s song, “Centerfield,” meant whatever you were watching needed a sound track, over track or background score to clue you in that it had something to do with the game;

= Ron Luciano, retired umpire, wrote another self-deprecating book. While pitching Miller Lite beer. After trying to become a national baseball TV analyst. He needed to be heard, seen and, if possible, felt, and hope you were entertained.

If Fernando Valenzuela and Pete Rose generated the most baseball relatable headlines in the ‘80s, Luciano created the most commentary about it and much more.

The 6-foot-4, 240-pound former All-American Syracuse offensive/defensive lineman who bridged the Orangemen teams in the late ‘50s of Jim Brown and Ernie Davis was drafted in 1959 as the last pick in the third round, No. 36 overall, by the NFL’s Detroit Lions. He wasn’t healthy enough to pursue that, or to teaching, so he turned to umpiring school in Florida, thought he was decent at it, and that’s where his path took him.

Continue reading “Day 19 of 2025 baseball book reviews: Unlucky Luciano’s last out”